Data Quadrant Awards 2023

Manufacturing Execution

SoftwareReviews names AVEVA Manufacturing Execution System, TilliT, Honeywell MES, Werum PAS-X, and Tulip as Manufacturing Execution Data Quadrant Award Winners.

View Category

Manufacturing Execution

Data Quadrant

Data Quadrants are proudly founded in 100% user review data and are free of traditional "magical" components such as market presence and analyst opinion, which are opaque in nature and may be influenced by vendor pressure, financial or otherwise.

The SoftwareReviews Data Quadrant evaluates and ranks products based on feedback from IT and business professionals. The placement of a software in the Data Quadrant indicates its relative ranking as well as its categorization.

Read The In-Depth Report

A thorough evaluation and ranking of all software in an individual category to compare software across every dimension.

user satisfaction rankings
|
vendor capability comparisons
|
business value scores
|
individual feature evaluations
|
emotional connection to products

Download Now

30+ pages

Note Software product placement is based on the scores provided by users, recency of the reviews, and review volume. Axes are dynamically adjusted based on the minimum and maximum values in the data set.

Evaluate the Complete

Software Experience

When distilled down, the software experience is shaped by both the experience with the software and the relationship with the vendor. Evaluating enterprise software along these two dimensions provides a comprehensive understanding of the product and helps identify vendors that can deliver on both.

Product Features and Satisfaction

The satisfaction is captured in the overall satisfaction score, which is driven by the likelihood of users to recommend the software, combined with user satisfaction across top product features.

Vendor Experience and Capabilities

The vendor relationship is calculated in a weighted average of the satisfaction scores tied to vendor capabilities (e.g. software implementation, training, customer support, product roadmap) as well as emotional response ratings toward the vendor (e.g. trustworthy, respectful, fair).

Gold Medalists

17Reviews

Schneider Electric Industrial Software

AVEVA Manufacturing Execution System

Maximize profitability, quality, and compliance of manufacturing operations

8.6

Composite
Score

+88

Emotional
Footprint

87%

Likeliness to
Recommend

Likeliness
to Recommend

Write a Review

Product Report

15+
pages

15Reviews

TilliT

The TilliT Digital Manufacturing Operations Platform enables fully paperless operations by integrating production, quality, and maintenance processes in a single no-code cloud platform. Light-weight and easily deployed TilliT combines asset performance monitoring, OEE, work order execution, quality management and production scheduling driven by workflow automation and optimization. By connecting to existing equipment or by using our suite of IoT sensors, TilliT brings together people, processes and equipment for complete operational control.

8.2

Composite
Score

+86

Emotional
Footprint

84%

Likeliness to
Recommend

Likeliness
to Recommend

Write a Review

Product Report

15+
pages

13Reviews

Honeywell International Inc.

Honeywell MES

Honeywell's MES Platform delivers a modular solution built to improve operations efficiency, drive compliance and accelerate digital transformation. Designed to integrate seamlessly with existing ERP systems, it requires no programming knowledge for deployment.

8.1

Composite
Score

+88

Emotional
Footprint

78%

Likeliness to
Recommend

Likeliness
to Recommend

Write a Review

Product Report

15+
pages

13Reviews

Korber Pharma

Werum PAS-X

Paperless MES software solution streamlining GMP and FDA-regulated pharmaceutical and bio-pharmaceutical production.

8.1

Composite
Score

+81

Emotional
Footprint

89%

Likeliness to
Recommend

Likeliness
to Recommend

Write a Review

Product Report

15+
pages

13Reviews

Tulip

Reliably execute processes and capture the information you need – with the agility and frontline guidance your operations require.

7.9

Composite
Score

+91

Emotional
Footprint

75%

Likeliness to
Recommend

Likeliness
to Recommend

Write a Review

Product Report

15+
pages

Vendor Capability Awards

Availability and Quality of Training

TilliT

Breadth of Features

AVEVA Manufacturing Execution System

Business Value Created

iBASEt MES

Ease of Customization

AVEVA Manufacturing Execution System

Ease of Data Integration

AVEVA Manufacturing Execution System

Ease of IT Administration

AVEVA Manufacturing Execution System

Ease of Implementation

AVEVA Manufacturing Execution System

Product Strategy and Rate of Improvement

SAP Manufacturing Execution

Quality of Features

AVEVA Manufacturing Execution System

Usability and Intuitiveness

TilliT

Vendor Support

aspenONE Manufacturing Execution Systems

Vendor Capability Awards

Availability and Quality of Training

TilliT

Breadth of Features

AVEVA Manufacturing Execution System

Business Value Created

iBASEt MES

Ease of Customization

AVEVA Manufacturing Execution System

Ease of Data Integration

AVEVA Manufacturing Execution System

Ease of IT Administration

AVEVA Manufacturing Execution System

Ease of Implementation

AVEVA Manufacturing Execution System

Product Strategy and Rate of Improvement

SAP Manufacturing Execution

Quality of Features

AVEVA Manufacturing Execution System

Usability and Intuitiveness

TilliT

Vendor Support

aspenONE Manufacturing Execution Systems

Other Evaluated Vendors

11Reviews

Aspen Technology

aspenONE Manufacturing Execution Systems

How do you effectively collect, manage and leverage the vast amount of data within your organization? The key is an efficient Manufacturing Execution System (MES). Based on the ISA-S95 framework, aspenONE® MES delivers efficient data management, operational intelligence via rich visualization and analytics, and improved production execution—enabling process manufacturers to quickly identify and resolve operational issues.

7.8

Composite
Score

+79

Emotional
Footprint

83%

Likeliness to
Recommend

Likeliness
to Recommend

Write a Review

Product Report

15+
pages

19Reviews

SAP

SAP Manufacturing Execution

Digitally control, monitor, and automate your manufacturing operations to enable a production lot size of one.

7.8

Composite
Score

+68

Emotional
Footprint

80%

Likeliness to
Recommend

Likeliness
to Recommend

Write a Review

Product Report

15+
pages

15Reviews

iBASEt

iBASEt MES

iBASEt's Manufacturing Execution Systems (MES), Maintenance, Repair and Overhaul (MRO) and Enterprise Quality Management software systems are giving customers the power to monitor every aspect of production, quality and compliance efficiency. Throughout manufacturing, supply chain, and maintenance, repair and overhaul, the iBASEt Solumina suite of applications enable full shop floor to top floor manufacturing visibility, consistent practices, and continuous product and process improvement.

7.7

Composite
Score

+77

Emotional
Footprint

82%

Likeliness to
Recommend

Likeliness
to Recommend

Write a Review

Product Report

15+
pages

12Reviews

Rockwell Automation

Rockwell Automation MES

FactoryTalk® ProductionCentre is a comprehensive MES that can help you meet a range of productivity, quality, compliance and cost-saving goals. ProductionCentre integrates quality management and business analytics with paperless shop floor and repair execution. This improves operational efficiencies and helps you achieve and demonstrate regulatory compliance and high quality. Available solutions include single-plant, multiplant or industry-specific suites.

7.6

Composite
Score

+75

Emotional
Footprint

72%

Likeliness to
Recommend

Likeliness
to Recommend

Write a Review

Product Report

15+
pages

24Reviews

Plex Systems

Plex MES

With a complete, unified set of ERP solutions, the Plex Manufacturing Cloud drives continuous improvements across your manufacturing enterprise.

7.4

Composite
Score

+58

Emotional
Footprint

87%

Likeliness to
Recommend

Likeliness
to Recommend

Write a Review

Product Report

15+
pages

15Reviews

CIMx Software LLC

CIMx Quantum MES Platform

MES for Your Manufacturing - Every shop we enter has a way to move work around the shop. Many use a simple routing from their ERP; some have a more detailed job packet. Whatever you use, it's likely you have gaps in the processes that you use. Close those critical gaps with a design to delivery, end-to-end set of tools for complete Production Control. Run your shop Operations. Build a production schedule that automatically prioritizes your current work, no matter the circumstances. Get the Business Analytics you need at the touch of a button with Quantum.

7.4

Composite
Score

+71

Emotional
Footprint

73%

Likeliness to
Recommend

Likeliness
to Recommend

Write a Review

Product Report

15+
pages

17Reviews

Sepasoft, Inc.

Sepasoft MES

Sepasoft® MES solutions provide you with the tools you need to efficiently manage your MES data without spending too much time custom-building your own solution. Read more below to find out which solution best suits your needs!

6.9

Composite
Score

+61

Emotional
Footprint

74%

Likeliness to
Recommend

Likeliness
to Recommend

Write a Review

Product Report

15+
pages

10Reviews

MPDV USA

MPDV MES HYDRA X

HYDRA MES gives users the ability to track orders, machines, tools, quality, materials, and labor in real time and historically. With low code, HTML based operator screens and management dashboards, and technical support that will have an immediate impact on your manufacturing operations, HYDRA is the go-to for enterprises needing better process control. Machine connectivity, seamless integration with ERP and sister systems, and assembly operator guidance make for a complete solution.

6.8

Composite
Score

+59

Emotional
Footprint

78%

Likeliness to
Recommend

Likeliness
to Recommend

Write a Review

Product Report

15+
pages

16Reviews

Siemens Digital Industries Software

Siemens MES

Siemens’ Manufacturing Execution System (MES) ensures that quality and efficiency are built into the manufacturing process and that they are proactively and systematically enforced. The Manufacturing Execution System connects multiple plants and sites, and integrates easily with equipment, controllers, product lifecycle and enterprise business applications, quality management and laboratory management systems, and many other applications. The result is complete visibility, control and optimization of production and processes across the enterprise.

6.5

Composite
Score

+57

Emotional
Footprint

73%

Likeliness to
Recommend

Likeliness
to Recommend

Write a Review

Product Report

15+
pages

10Reviews

Dassault Systemes

DELMIAWorks MES

DELMIA Enterprise MES goes far beyond traditional factory MES operations to include all related operations and information sources, and leverages the IoT (Internet of Things) for a truly global solution. DELMIA enables manufacturers to take control of their operations everywhere in the enterprise to coordinate and synchronize people, processes, equipment, tooling and materials on a global scale.

6.3

Composite
Score

+48

Emotional
Footprint

79%

Likeliness to
Recommend

Likeliness
to Recommend

Write a Review

Product Report

15+
pages

For the full list of vendors in this space, click here.

SoftwareReviews Gold Medal Awards recognize outstanding vendors in the technology marketplace as evaluated by their users. Gold Medals are the capstone of an in-depth software evaluation report, and awarded using a proprietary, transparent methodology based on a composite satisfaction score that averages four different areas of evaluation: Net Emotional Footprint, Vendor Capabilities, Product Features, and Likeliness to Recommend. The Net Emotional Footprint Score measures user emotional response ratings of the vendor (e.g. trustworthy, respectful, fair).

Software Reports present comprehensive evaluations of software vendors on the above elements. Software buyers can use this data to make more informed, data-driven software purchasing and renewal decisions.